Volkscentrum

Socialistisch educatief webblog

Anti-imperialisme nu, antikapitalisme later

Over de prioriteiten van links in het Westen

Kladversie. De Engelse tekst hieronder moet nog vertaald worden.

Dit is een vertaling van Anti-Imperialism Now, Anti-Capitalism Later van Earl Robson, oorspronkelijk verschenen in The Pseudonymous Left.[1]

Communism is an international movement. The goal is not socialism in one country (although the Bolsheviks proved this possible) it is socialism globally. However, this does not mean that communist movements must struggle for global socialism in the immediate moment. Again, as demonstrated by the Bolsheviks, each nation’s people must struggle for socialism within their own country. This is where I believe the western left, especially those who advocate immediate revolution within the imperial core, have erred.

Mao taught all future communists an important lesson. The primary contradiction is not always class struggle within one’s own nation. He transcribed this in theory when he wrote “On Contradiction”,[2] but went further still. He proved this to be the case when he made the correct decision in allying with the KMT against the Japanese fascists. In properly analyzing the material conditions of China, the communists found the correct line. Socialism could not be brought to China if the Japanese won. The primary contradiction was not of class, it was of country. Chinese communism could never have been brought about if not for their anti-imperialist struggle.

I believe global communism finds itself in a similar predicament to the Chinese communists during their resistance against Japan. Socialism, not just in one country, but in nearly every country, can not be brought about until the anti-imperialist struggle is won. Imperialism lessens the contradictions of capitalism within the imperial core, while exacerbating them in the periphery. Imperialism can be ended in the third world through ascendance into socialism, and socialism can only be realized in the first through the end of imperialism. The material interest of the west is to maintain imperialism. There will be no socialist America as long as the American proletariat can subsist on imperialist superprofits. The bourgeoisie has managed to get the western proletariat invested in capitalism by materially incentivizing their adherence to imperialism.

It is only through identifying and accepting this to be the primary contradiction of our time that communists can follow the proper course of action. Only with this clarity do prescriptions that before would have seemed incoherent become entirely rational. Higher taxes, for example, must be opposed by communists in America. If Bernie Sanders got his wish and we “taxed the 1%” the vast majority of it would simply get funneled directly into the military industrial complex, which would then be used to police the third world and uphold global capitalism. We should not seek to tax more, we should seek to spend less on the military.

The primary concern of the western left should not be healthcare for Americans. This comes at great expense of the third world. The only explanation for this being a person’s top priority is that they simply value the lives of Americans more than the global poor. While socialism in one country is indeed possible, a material analysis that ignores the broader world will never achieve that.

Bronnen

  1. Earl Robson, “Anti-Imperialism Now, Anti-Capitalism Later”, The Pseudonymous Left, 24 mei 2023. De oorspronkelijke pagina is gearchiveerd: web.archive.org ↩
  2. Mao Zedong, Over de tegenstelling (1937). ↩