Volkscentrum

Socialistisch educatief webblog

De mythe van het autoritaire

Over de staat, geweld en autoriteit

Kladversie. De Engelse tekst hieronder moet nog vertaald worden.

Dit is een vertaling van The Myth of the Authoritarian van Earl Robson, oorspronkelijk verschenen in The Pseudonymous Left.[1]

Authoritarianism is a condemnation often hurled about between political opponents, especially at those on both the left and right, who find themselves far outside the safety of neoliberal ideology. The accusation is thought terminating, emotionally charged, and quite often baseless. Implicit in this framing is the idea that certain states have more authority over their populace than others. This is an absurd and infantile view of the world.

In order to illustrate this, we must examine the source of a state’s authority. Some will propose that this varies depending on the nature of the state. They will say, for example, that a constitutional democracy derives its power from the consent of the majority, while a “totalitarian dictatorship” will obtain and uphold its authority with its ability to control the populace by exerting force. These are idealist myths, told by those who view the world through aesthetics and are incapable of looking beyond. Max Weber defined the state as the “human community that claims monopoly on the legitimate use of physical force within its territory”.[2] Here, Weber identified the real source of authority, regardless of the details of a government’s function. That source is violence. However, I would like to propose an amendment to this definition of the state. Rather, I would argue that the state has a monopoly on determining what is legitimate violence. An individual engaging in self defense can be deemed legitimate, while a police officer using excessive force can have their legitimacy revoked.

But if the state derives its power from violence, what is violence? Colloquially, this refers to physical violence: fistfights, shootings, stabbing and any other horrid things you could imagine. In the political sense however, this definition is woefully inadequate. Violence can be instead defined as the imposition of the will of one over another by use or threat of force. This necessarily implies the existence of a state in any form is violent. Some may be skeptical of this claim, considering the relative rarity with which the state exercises force on its populace in bourgeois democracies, but this contention will be addressed later. Rather, I find it more pressing to note that if this premise can be taken to be true, the idea of an “anti-authoritarian” position is already largely nonsensical. All states have absolute authority over the territory and people they control, meaning political disagreements are reduced to the ends with which this power is wielded, not to the extent the state has power, for a state that does not maintain an absolute monopoly on determining legitimate violence ceases to be a state.

Now of course those who see the world as aesthetics and nothing more will take great issue with these claims. Can it really be said that the government of Norway is as dependent on the use of violence as that of a fascist state? Is a state’s ability to enforce traffic laws as rooted in capacity for force as its ability to practice capital punishment? The answer is, of course, yes. Indeed, more “civilized” nations do not often murder protesters en masse, instead they are more reliant on the threat of violence. But this is a mere abstraction, the state’s authority is no less absolute or of a different origin than that of a brutal regime.

Let us take the most mundane of examples: parking tickets. If one parks on a street that is off limits for that use, they incur the risk of a traffic officer serving them a ticket. This is a fine the individual must pay to the state, but where does this authority come from? Who are they to tell you where you can park your own car on a public street? If one is sufficiently indignant at this authority of the state imposing itself on their sovereign will, they may venture to refuse paying the fine. This of course runs the risk of imprisonment, and further resistance of that leads to ever increasing violent retaliation. The authority of the state to impose its will on an individual, even for something as minor as parking laws, is derived from violence. No matter how abstracted this violence is, it is still the ultimate authority of this that allows the state to uphold its policies.

Some may maliciously misinterpret this as a claim that all governments are equally brutal. Obviously, this is not the claim. Rather, it is to be understood that all states are “authoritarian”—they have absolute power over their people. No matter how many “checks and balances” a piece of paper claims a state has, these can ultimately be overturned, ignored, or exploited by a sufficiently malicious force. No system of governance is completely immune to corruption or coup. The distinction between a liberal democracy and a dictatorship, therefore, rests solely in the utilization of this absolute authority.

In response to this information, one usually must either become a full fledged anarchist, pledging the abolition of all states, or instead focus solely on productive uses of authority, rather than fear mongering over the existence of it. I, like most others, choose the latter. This specter of authoritarianism is a malicious construct. It benefits the status quo exclusively. When the current system is seen as a default, or even a product of natural laws, the use of the state to enact a new system will be decried as “authoritarian”, while ignoring the authority used to uphold the current system and refusing to engage with proposed alternatives. Capitalism, the private ownership of the means of production, is often seen as something independent of the state. This is a gross misrepresentation of the truth of the world. Even when capitalism functions perfectly, and businesses require no bail outs, and there are no boom and bust cycles, a state is still required. After all, what but a government could uphold private property, contracts, or the bare minimum amount of regulation necessary for markets to form in the first place? In the absence of such authoritarian controls on free enterprise, it is certain that a system of free and fair competition would be impossible to arise. How then, is it more authoritarian to use the state to supplant one economic system with another? Undoubtedly, it is not.

Bronnen

  1. Earl Robson, “The Myth of the Authoritarian”, The Pseudonymous Left, 11 april 2023. De oorspronkelijke pagina is gearchiveerd: web.archive.org ↩
  2. Max Weber, Politik als Beruf (Politiek als beroep), lezing uit 1919. ↩