Volkscentrum

Socialistisch educatief webblog

De zaak voor genderafschaffing

Een marxistisch perspectief

Kladversie. De Engelse tekst hieronder moet nog vertaald worden.

Dit is een vertaling van The Case for Gender Abolition: A Marxist Perspective van Earl Robson, oorspronkelijk verschenen in The Pseudonymous Left.[1]

I. Introduction

Gender is one of the most divisive subjects of our time. Those who are otherwise apolitical have become single-issue activists about the gender question. For this reason, I find it necessary to make my position clear.

As Marxists, we must begin with the material: sex. A common misconception is that sex is binary. This is unscientific and undialectical. Sex is bimodal. There are opposites, male and female, with unities between the two. Sex also does not determine one’s behavior. People are often socialized to behave in a way that the culture has deemed aligns with their sex, yes, but that is not a result of sex itself but of the societal attitude towards it. The behavioral aspect—how one acts, speaks, dresses, etc.—is what’s known as gender. The masculine and feminine genders exist as opposites. But what exactly are these opposites?

Gender is not an internal phenomenon. Those who believe in self-identification theory are correct when they say that gender is a social construct, but by that very definition, gender is a social phenomenon. Gender exists between individuals, not within them. Genders are socially defined roles people perform. These roles are culturally defined.

II. Historical Development of Gender

As all social phenomena do, gender arose out of material conditions. The bourgeois and liberal feminists completely ignore this fact, and that is why their analysis inevitably leads them astray.

Gender roles and relations first arose due to the social division of reproductive labor. Women are expected to raise children while men perform labor to provide for the family unit. In contemporary times, there is absolutely nothing that justifies the inequality between men and women. The subjugation of women by men did arise partially due to biological differences (strength, birthing, etc.), but the main causes were economic. Alexandra Kollontai details this in “The Social Basis of the Woman Question”:[2]

“The followers of historical materialism reject the existence of a special woman question separate from the general social question of our day. Specific economic factors were behind the subordination of women; natural qualities have been a secondary factor in this process. Only the complete disappearance of these factors, only the evolution of those forces that at some point in the past gave rise to the subjection of women, is able in a fundamental way to influence and change their social position. In other words, women can become truly free and equal only in a world organized along new social and productive lines.”

Given that the material basis of gender is economic, it follows that as the mode of economic production changes, so too will gender. Change the base, and the superstructure changes as well. There is nothing inherent to man or woman as genders; to think otherwise is pure idealism; it is the belief in a Platonic ideal of man and woman. While the particulars of gender are unique to each culture (traditional dress, manners, etc.), the mode of reproductive labor is nearly universal. In the Americas, Europe, Africa, and Asia, we see women being subjected to patriarchal oppression. Women are expected to perform reproductive labor—the raising and caretaking of children—by themselves, and as capitalism further develops, they are increasingly expected to do this in addition to wage labor. How many mothers work multiple jobs in addition to raising the next generation? What causes this—is it an innate biological feature of the female sex, or is it a product of the present mode of production? It is arguably the latter.

Already, it is clear that gender essentialists are incorrect. Gender cannot be conflated with sex, as the social relations of gender are based on cultural and economic relations rather than inherent biology.

However, those who subscribe to self-identification theory are also incorrect. Gender cannot possibly be an entirely individualistic experience. A social construct requires social participation. Gender is performative; it is a set of behaviors that one engages in. These behaviors are culturally defined, but they are not an idea in one’s mind but rather an external trait others perceive you as. Now, this is not to say one’s gender must align with their sex, but rather that thinking to oneself, “I am a man,” does not make one a man.

III. Gender as a Tool of Reproduction in Class Society

Gender has always been a powerful weapon of the ruling class. It is a tool with which those in control can shape social relations as well as the mode of reproduction. The monogamous family is based entirely on the dominance of women by men, with men looking to sire children as their property and heirs. According to Engels in “The Origins of the Family”, “It is based on the supremacy of the man, the express purpose being to produce children of undisputed paternity; such paternity is demanded because these children are later to come into their father’s property as his natural heirs.”[3] Women are not paid a wage for their reproductive labor as men are for their labor in this system; rather, women are both property of men and recipients of what their husbands decide to provide them. The wife labors, yet she still depends on the husband to earn a wage and be the breadwinner.

This oppression of women by men can destroy “comradely solidarity,” as Kollontai puts it. The emancipation of women cannot come as a result of reactionary hatred of men; it can only be achieved by creating a new social order with a new mode of production. This is where the bourgeois feminists are wrong: without the science of dialectical materialism to guide their analysis, they believe that legal rights before the liberal state will achieve true equality for women. This is entirely mistaken. A woman who has the right to vote but is still subjugated by the model of the traditional family remains materially oppressed.

IV. The Case for Gender Abolition

If gender arises out of material conditions and is in no way a natural trait of humanity, does it have any utility? After all, what use is there in socially defined roles that demand people fill certain preordained gender roles where one must act and dress a certain way? I cannot find any.

One might argue that while gender may not have much utility, it is impossible to abolish due to human biology. This is an absurd argument to make, considering the breadth of gender expression across cultures. Why do Sunni women wear hijabs while Christian women do not? Is there some gene within the predominately Sunni populations that causes them to do so? No, of course not. Perhaps, while the particularity of gender differs by culture, there are “male and female brains” that express themselves differently based on social context. This is objectively and scientifically false. On average, differences between male and female brains are incredibly minor. In addition to this, those with “male brains” have been documented to perform womanhood, and vice versa, as evidenced by transgender people. There are no sound arguments in favor of biological gender.

Even so, the fact that gender is an entirely social construct is not an argument for its abolition. Some social constructs are useful, but as Marx said, we must engage in ruthless criticism of all that exists. Only after ruthless critique can one determine the utility of anything.

Gender roles are roles one performs. They exist not as an internal feeling but as social relations between people. To be any gender is to feel the pressure of performing that gender and fulfilling your assigned role. Would it not be simpler to be rid of this structure and exist simply as humans? Instead of being a “man” or a “woman” or something in between, one could exist simply as a person who chooses to behave and express themselves as they see fit.

The oppression and exploitation of women are also inarguably dependent on the existence of gender. Gender roles arose due to the division of reproductive labor and now exist to continue to reinforce this system. True emancipation of the female sex results from both the abolition of the present mode of production and gender roles. To abolish gender roles is to abolish gender itself.

V. Conclusion

Now, am I arguing that we force everyone to be nonbinary? Of course not. Rather, I am arguing that social change to abolish gender would both be possible and beneficial. We do not need the state to arrest everyone using gendered pronouns; rather, we need a bottom-up social movement. The queer community won acceptance in the West without the state forcing people to have gay sex, and I believe the same can be done for gender abolition. A grassroots movement advocating the abolishment of gendered language and society could achieve its goals without force.

In addition to this, gender abolition seems to be the inevitable result of the communist mode of production. After all, in a society where all are truly equal, not just before the law but in material reality and in an economic sense, gender will have even less utility than it does now. When people are compensated for their reproductive labor and women do not need to sell themselves to men in the form of prostitution or traditional marriage, the need for gender roles to enforce these structures will disappear.

Communism is the real movement that abolishes the present state of things, and it will also be the movement to abolish gender.

Bronnen

  1. Earl Robson, “The Case for Gender Abolition: A Marxist Perspective”, The Pseudonymous Left, 23 juli 2023. De oorspronkelijke pagina is gearchiveerd: web.archive.org ↩
  2. Alexandra Kollontai, The Social Basis of the Woman Question (1909). ↩
  3. Friedrich Engels, De oorsprong van het gezin, van de particuliere eigendom en van de staat (1884), hoofdstuk II. ↩